Electric vehicles have taken the Indian market by storm, and the subcompact SUV segment is no exception. Two new contenders vying for dominance in this space are the 2024 Tata Punch EV and the Citroen eC3. Both offer compelling propositions, but which one comes out on top? Let’s dive into a detailed comparison of their specifications to find out.
Design and Dimensions:
- Tata Punch EV: The Punch EV retains the boxy SUV design of its ICE counterpart but gets a modern makeover with sleek connected LED DRLs, split headlights and fog lamps, and a redesigned bumper. It measures 3827 mm in length, 1742 mm in width, and 1615 mm in height, with a wheelbase of 2445 mm.
- Citroen eC3: The eC3 boasts a quirky and youthful design with a wide grille, split headlamps, and muscular wheel arches. It’s slightly larger than the Punch EV, measuring 3981 mm in length, 1735 mm in width, and 1606 mm in height, with a wheelbase of 2636 mm.
Powertrain and Performance:
- Tata Punch EV: The Punch EV comes with two battery pack options: 26 kWh and 30 kWh. The 26 kWh version offers a range of 310 km, while the 30 kWh variant boasts a range of up to 350 km (ARAI certified). It churns out 75 PS (55 kW) of power and 170 Nm of torque, mated to a front-wheel-drive configuration with an automatic transmission.
- Citroen eC3: The eC3 comes with a single 29.3 kWh battery pack delivering a range of 327 km (ARAI certified). Its electric motor produces 57 PS (42 kW) of power and 143 Nm of torque, also driving the front wheels through an automatic transmission.
| Punch EV Standard Range | Punch EV Long Range | Citroen eC3 | |
| Power And Torque | 82 PS/114 Nm | 122 PS/190 Nm | 57 PS/143 Nm |
| Battery Pack | 25 kWh | 35 kWh | 29.2 kWh |
| Top Speed | 110 kmph | 140 kmph | 107 kmph |
| ARAI-claimed range | 315 km(Expected) | 400 km(Expected) | 320 km |
Features and Technology:
- Tata Punch EV: The Punch EV is packed with features, including dual 10.25-inch displays for infotainment and instrument cluster, ventilated front seats, an optional sunroof, a 360-degree camera, and wireless charging capabilities. It also gets Tata’s ZConnect connected car suite with a host of features.
- Citroen eC3: The eC3 features a touchscreen infotainment system with Apple CarPlay and Android Auto compatibility, automatic climate control, a multi-function steering wheel, and cruise control. It also gets some connected car features through the Citroen Connect app.
Safety:
- Both vehicles come equipped with standard safety features like dual airbags, ABS with EBD, and ISOFIX child seat anchorage points. However, the Punch EV offers additional features like cornering stability control and hill hold control.
Price:
- Tata Punch EV’s expected price range starts from Rs 9.50 lakh and goes up to Rs 14.60 lakh (ex-showroom).
- Citroen eC3’s prices start from Rs 11.61 lakh and go up to Rs 12.79 lakh (ex-showroom).
Verdict:
Choosing between the Tata Punch EV and the Citroen eC3 depends on your priorities. If you prioritize range, features, and performance, the Punch EV might be the better choice. However, if you prefer a slightly larger and more quirky design and are on a tighter budget, the eC3 could be a good option. Ultimately, both vehicles offer compelling propositions in the growing Indian electric vehicle market, and the choice will come down to individual preferences and needs.
Additional Considerations:
- Charging infrastructure: While both vehicles support DC fast charging, the availability of charging stations might vary depending on your location.
- Test drive: It’s always recommended to take both vehicles for a test drive to get a feel for their driving dynamics and features before making a decision.
With its longer range, higher power output, and feature-rich package, the Tata Punch EV appears to edge out the Citroen eC3 in this head-to-head comparison. However, the eC3’s quirky design, larger size, and slightly lower price might appeal to some buyers. Ultimately, the best choice for you will depend on your individual needs and preferences.